Short answer: the grades are real but not standardised, and they mean something slightly different from eBay’s scale. In the China-to-overseas trade, “Excellent” generally means fully working with cosmetic marks you would not notice from two metres. “Like New” means the unit has under 20 hours on it. “As-Is” means nobody tested it — price it as a parts lot.
What do the standard labels mean?
| Label | What it usually covers | Expected discount vs new |
|---|---|---|
| Like New / Mint | Under 20 hours, original box, no marks | 50–65% |
| Excellent | Working 100%, light rack rash, no dents | 65–80% |
| Good | Working, visible scuffs, maybe new grille | 75–85% |
| Fair / Used | Works but cosmetically rough | 85%+ |
| As-Is / Untested | No test done, no guarantee | Any — treat as parts |
Why does grading vary so much between sellers?
Because there is no trade body enforcing it. A dealer grading 200 units a week is usually consistent with themselves. A dealer selling one desk they bought at auction may be using “Excellent” to mean “it powered on.” The grade reflects the seller’s habit, not an industry code.
Our practice is to grade against function first and cosmetics second, and to say so in the listing. If a speaker cone has a 3 mm tear that does not affect output, we call it Good, not Excellent — even though it will sound identical. Buyers who open a box expecting a 3 mm tear to be absent are the ones who file disputes.
What questions expose a lazy grade?
- “How many hours of use?” If the answer is a number, the seller tracks their stock. If it is “it looks great,” move on.
- “Can you send a photo of the serial plate and the rear panel connectors?” Cosmetic photos hide corroded XLR pins; rear-panel shots do not.
- “What exactly is not working, even if minor?” A seller who says “nothing” on a 12-year-old desk is guessing.
Does cosmetic grade affect resale later?
Less than you think. A used K-array or JBL speaker with rack rash sells for 5–10% less than a clean one — nothing like the 20% difference the grade label implies. Functional condition dominates. What really hurts resale is missing accessories: a console without its power supply or a speaker without its rigging pin set loses 15–20%.
How should you price an As-Is listing?
As a parts lot. A 48-channel digital console sold As-Is at $400 is a bet that the fault is one fader; the same desk working is $1,300. Only take that bet if you can diagnose it yourself. Otherwise pay the extra $900 for a tested unit — like the tested used Yamaha DM1000 we list with a flight case, where “Excellent” means we powered it, swept every fader, and measured phantom power on all channels.
Is ‘Like New’ ever worth the premium?
Sometimes. On speakers, drivers are rated for 1,000+ hours and a low-hour unit genuinely has more life left. On consoles, less so — fader wear is the failure mode, and “Like New” consoles rarely carry proof of low hours. Spend the premium on speakers and microphones; save it on desks. Full stock is in the used speakers category.
Key Takeaways
- Excellent = working with light cosmetic marks; Like New = under 20 hours; As-Is = untested parts lot.
- Grades are seller habits, not an enforced standard — ask for hours, serial, and rear-panel photos.
- Cosmetics move resale 5–10%; missing accessories cost 15–20%.
- Pay the ‘Like New’ premium on speakers and mics, skip it on consoles.
