Daily Q&A

What do ‘Excellent’ and ‘Like New’ mean when a used audio gear listing says it?

Answered on November 15, 2026

Condition grades on used audio gear are seller-defined, not industry-defined. “Like New” usually means the item was unboxed and used a handful of times with no marks; “Excellent” means it works perfectly and shows only minor scuffs. Neither word tells you anything about driver cones, capacitor age or fader wear, so ask for photos and a serial number before you pay.

Is there one grading scale everyone uses?

No. Reverb has its own Mint-to-Poor ladder, eBay sellers invent their own, and Chinese exporters often map four Chinese grades onto English words loosely. A “9成新” listing translates to roughly “90% new”, which sounds reassuring and means very little.

Treat grades as a rough filter, never as a spec. The useful question is not “how many stars” but “what has been replaced, what is worn, and does it still measure in spec”.

What should each grade realistically allow?

GradeCosmetic realityFunctional realityTypical discount
Like NewNo visible marks, original boxUnder 20 hours of use60-75% of new price
ExcellentLight scuffs, faded grille badgeAll drivers original, all pots clean45-60% of new price
GoodScratches, chipped corner, worn handleWorks, may need re-cone or re-cap soon30-40% of new price
Fair / PartsHeavy cosmetic damageIntermittent or dead channelUnder 25%, salvage value

Discount bands vary by brand. A K-array KF12 holds value far better than a no-name 12-inch box, because buyers know the drivers are worth something on their own. When a seller offers a famous model at 30% off and calls it “excellent”, that is the moment to look harder, not to celebrate.

Which faults actually matter for a speaker?

  • Voice coil rub. Push the cone gently; any scraping sound means a re-cone, around $120-200 for a 12-inch driver.
  • Foam rot. A 15-year-old surround can crumble. Look for orange dust in the grille.
  • Horn diaphragm cracks. Cheap to fix, easy to miss until the top end sounds dull.
  • Grille dents. Cosmetic only. Ignore them.
  • Missing rigging hardware. A flying frame can cost more than the discount you got.

What about consoles and amplifiers?

For a mixing console, the cosmetic grade is nearly meaningless. What matters is fader wear, scratchy gain pots and whether the power supply has been recapped. A Yamaha DM1000 from 2004 with a clean flight case and no dead faders is a better buy than one that “looks new” but has three sticky channels. We list these with real photos and honest notes on the used Yamaha DM1000 console page, serial visible, so you can judge for yourself.

On amps, look for signs of repair: mismatched screws, scorched PCB areas, new capacitors on one channel only. An amp described as “excellent” that has clearly been opened twice is a “good” at best.

Six questions to send the seller before paying

  1. Can you send a photo of the serial number plate?
  2. Have any drivers, diaphragms or faders been replaced?
  3. How many hours or events has it been used for, roughly?
  4. Was it ever run without a limiter or driven into clip?
  5. Is the original flight case or packaging included?
  6. Can you shoot a 30-second video of it powering up and passing signal?

A seller who answers all six quickly is usually describing the gear accurately. One who gets vague about serial numbers is worth walking away from, whatever the grade says.

Do photos and video prove anything?

Photos of a clean grille prove nothing. Ask specifically for: both side panels, the rear connector panel, the serial plate, and the inside of the horn. Then ask for a 30-second clip of the unit powering up with music playing, filmed in one take, no cuts. Sellers who stage photos rarely send a continuous clip, because a continuous clip shows the things they would rather you did not see.

If the seller is an exporter and the unit is in a different country, ask for a short video call with the gear powered at their warehouse. That single request filters out 80% of misdescribed listings, and it takes them five minutes.

Is it worth paying more for a graded item?

Only when the dealer offers a written functional guarantee alongside the grade. A grade without a return window is decoration. A grade with a 7-day test-and-return policy is worth maybe 10-15% more, because that policy is the seller putting money behind the description.

For passive speakers, that guarantee matters less, since a driver test tells you most of what you need. For digital consoles and powered cabinets, a guarantee is genuinely valuable, because their failures take longer to surface than a single test session allows.

Pair this with a matching cabinet or desk before you commit: JBL KP4010 passive 10-inch speaker. Both are listed with real photos and serial-level notes, so you can check condition yourself.

Key Takeaways

  • “Like New” and “Excellent” are marketing words, not standards. Always ask for the specifics behind them.
  • Expect 45-60% of new price for genuinely excellent used gear; a steeper discount usually hides a repair.
  • Cosmetic dents are fine. Voice coil rub, foam rot and dead faders are not.
  • Serial numbers and a power-up video catch more lies than any photo of a clean grille.