A used Shure SM58 sells for $45-70 in 2026. A new one is $99. That gap is too small to chase one mic, and it is exactly why buying used SM58s makes sense only when you need ten of them, or when you need a labeled spare for a mic that already belongs to a venue.
Why is the used price so close to new?
Because the SM58 survives almost everything. Drop it, tape it, run it through a washing machine by accident: the capsule keeps working. When a product refuses to die, the used market never fills up with bargains. Prices stay at 45-70% of new for decades.
The other side of that: a used SM58 with a crushed grille is worth $20 because grilles cost $12-15 and a buyer will pay for the ball. Do not let a seller tell you a crushed grille is cosmetic. It changes how the capsule handles plosives.
How do you spot a counterfeit SM58?
- Weight: a genuine SM58 is about 298 g. Fakes are lighter, often 230-260 g.
- Grille mesh: genuine mesh is dense and even. Fake mesh is coarser and reflects light differently.
- XLR pins: genuine pins are gold-plated and evenly spaced. Fakes are tin and often wobbly.
- Screw on the yoke: genuine has a specific slotted screw; fakes use a Phillips.
Serial numbers are not reliable any more. Counters have copied real serials onto fake bodies for years. Weigh the mic and look at the grille, that is the test that still works.
Is the SM58 still the right vocal mic in 2026?
For loud stages with wedges, yes. The cardioid pattern, the 50 Hz to 15 kHz response and the built-in ball filter are still a good combination for a singer standing 3 cm from a wedge. For a quiet podcast, no: the SM58 has less low-end control than the SM7B and it picks up handling noise.
If you are buying for a venue that runs wedges, the SM58 is the cheapest reliable answer. If you already run in-ears and a cleaner stage, look at a used Beta58A at $90-130, which has a tighter pattern and more output. Both are worth having in a drawer.
What should you test in five minutes?
| Test | What you are checking |
|---|---|
| Weight in hand | Counterfeit or genuine |
| Speak at 5 cm | Capsule output and clarity |
| Tap the body | Loose capsule or bad solder joint |
| Wiggle the XLR | Connector wear |
| Spin the yoke screw | Thread condition |
Tap the body with a fingernail. A healthy SM58 gives a dull thud. A hollow ring means the capsule mount has come loose, and that mic will rattle on stage.
How do used SM58 and used Beta58A compare?
A used Beta58A runs $90-130 against $159 new. It has a tighter supercardioid pattern, more output and a smoother top end, but the tighter pattern also means a singer who moves off-axis loses level fast. On a crowded stage with wedges on both sides, that pattern rejection is worth the extra $50. In a small room, the SM58 is more forgiving.
Both share the same thread for stands and clips, so a mixed drawer works fine. The only thing you should never mix is the grille: an SM58 grille on a Beta58A body changes the response more than most people expect, and it happens constantly in venue drawers.
When is buying used a bad idea?
When you need five matching mics for a stage. Mismatched capsules mean mismatched gain and EQ, and a 15 dB difference across a stage is a mixing problem you will fight every show. In that case, pay the $99 and buy new from one batch.
When you need to know the mic is genuine and you cannot inspect it first, also buy new. The counterfeit risk is the real cost of the used route, not wear. Our used microphones category lists tested units with weight recorded, which is the detail most listings skip.
Key Takeaways
- A used SM58 runs $45-70 against $99 new, so buy in bulk or for spares.
- Weight is about 298 g; fakes usually run 230-260 g.
- A crushed grille costs $12-15 to fix and must be priced in.
- For matching stage mics, buy new from one batch instead.
Where to buy tested used mics
We weigh and photograph each microphone and record the result before shipping, so you know what you are getting. If you need a set of eight for a stage, message the export desk and we will match capsules from the same production run where stock allows.
